Below you will find another fantastic article from Clio’s Board Games, this time discussing Protestant player strategy in Here I Stand. You can also find this article on Clio’s blog. The previous articles in this series can be found here, here, and here. Enjoy! -Rachel
I haven’t done a strategy post in over a year! But I know you like them, so there will be more of them over the next months.
Today, we’re returning to a mainstay: Here I Stand (Ed Beach, GMT Games) is one of my favorite games ever – if not my favorite game of all. (I should really do one of those Top X games of all times posts!) So far, we’ve had three strategy articles for it already:
- How to Win as the Hapsburgs in Here I Stand
- How to Win as the Papacy in Here I Stand
- How to Win as England in Here I Stand
All of them have been in the tried-and-true fashion of giving three basic tips which new and intermediate players can easily remember. Today, we’re doing that with the faction whose emergence started the whole scenario for Here I Stand: The Protestants! They play a bit differently than most of the other factions. Here’s how to make the most of the explosive potential of this faction, to avoid the most dangerous trap for it, and to push yourself over the finish line once you have come out as a fully-fledged contender.
Go Big or Stay Home (Translating)
I’ve said it before: A victory at Here I Stand requires balancing between turns in which you conserve and consolidate your strength and turns in which you go all in. No power is better at this than the Protestants:
- Luther’s excellent admin rating allows you to carry two cards over to the next turn.
- Your Home Card lets you dive into the discard pile and retrieve one card which you can either play immediately or save for later.
Those two abilities combined give you excellent opportunities to build a great hand for the next turn. Say, you keep two cards and draw four the next turn (plus the Home Card) – that’s seven cards, already a lot. Now say one of the two cards you carry over is one of these gems which you’ve gotten from the discard pile:
That’s an amazing turn right there!
And when you decide that this turn is not suitable for going big (bad draw, too much pressure from your opponents, or maybe just your opponents being not distracted enough by the other players), you have a great thing to do in your consolidation turns: Translating!
- It’s extremely flexible – you can spend any amount of CP.
- You can use some debater bonuses.
- You can advance in three different languages.
Ideally, you have one or several translations almost ready with only or two CP left for your “big” turns. Combining a card which gives you reformation attempts and/or bonuses (like Printing Press) with all the attempts you get from finishing a translation will result in a big sweep of spaces which are suddenly Protestant.
Lucky Number Eleven: Delay the Schmalkaldic League
Now, let’s not overdo the converting of spaces in the beginning. One thing which you really need to be aware of before playing as the Protestants is how the Schmalkaldic League works.
The League is formed either when the respective mandatory event card is played and the Protestants have 12 or more spaces under their religious influence (from turn 2 on) or at the end of turn 4. Then, the Protestants become a full political and military power, which means that
- Any space under Protestant religious control which is printed on the board as such becomes a Protestant home space (automatically under Protestant political control as well)
- Electorates under Protestant political and religious control give the Protestants 2 VP each (so, 12 VP if you control all six of them) – electorates under Hapsburg political control give the Hapsburgs 1 VP
- The Protestants can now muster additional military forces and move them around – and, of course, they are now a valid target for attacks themselves!
The Schmalkaldic League is thus a double-edged sword. Of course you want the electorate VPs, but entering the political-military sphere of the game comes at the risk of Hapsburg campaigns against you. Thus, you want the event to happen as late as possible – so, at the end of turn 4. As you cannot control when the card will be drawn, you need to make sure that you do not fulfil the conditions for triggering the event as long as possible – and that means staying at a maximum of 11 Protestant spaces for as long as you can. Limit yourself to the most important spaces – so, the electorates, and any space you need to go from one electorate to the other.
Of course, once the Schmalkaldic League does happen, you want your dominion in Germany to be as large as possible, so turn 4 should definitely be a “big” turn as per the first tip.
Against Invasion: An Ounce of Sweat Saves a Gallon of Blood
Once the Schmalkaldic League is formed, you need to change your playstyle. Even though it might be tempting to stick to translating and publishing treatises (after all, Protestant spaces are what gets you VPs), I advise to invest into the defense of your territory early. Some CP spent on mercenaries in the vulnerable electorates go a long way in deterring Hapsburg invasions (electorates with one or two troops will just look like low-hanging fruit and invite the Emperor to spend his vacation in the Rhineland instead of the Balkans), and if the Hapsburgs invade anyway, having to fight their way through strongly defended electorates costs them time and troops – and, eventually, the Emperor will always have bigger fish to fry.
What are your strategies with the Protestants in Here I Stand? Let me know in the comments!
Nicely done. HIS is a great game. One of my favorites. I must admit, I never considered staying in low gear to forestall the creation of the Schmalkaldic League.
Thanks! Going all-in from the beginning can absolutely work for the Protestants as well, but I feel it paints too big a target on their back: The worst outcome is that you’re stuck with a 12-15 space Schmalkaldic League, and the Emperor is not at war yet with the Ottomans and immediately descends on you, and everybody else feels like you’re doing too well and does nothing to help you. So, I prefer to wait a little bit, pour CP into translations and explode on turn 4 with six cards plus home card and the German full Bible and a New Testament in English and/or French almost complete.